Winter’s grip is strong here in Bayfield, Wisconsin.

It’s -2 degrees Fahrenheit and a RealFeel of -10 degrees as I write this. Snow tornados are whipping across Seagull Bay’s parking lot. And while most of us are bundled up inside, there’s a particular group of hearty souls braving the chill…

Ice fishermen. 

Portable fishing tents are scattered on the ice of Lake Superior and the Apostle Islands. Perched inside these huts are dedicated fishermen busy jigging, watching their Vexilar, and waiting for the next bite.

Fishing in Bayfield, Wisconsin has deep roots. Isaac, for example, comes from a long line of commercial fishermen who have been part of this community for over 150 years. 

While we don’t fish commercially, Isaac and the boys love to grab a rod and reel and head down to the marina to cast a line whenever they can. 

As we transition from the icy grip of winter to the promise of spring, the anticipation of a new season grows. 

In Bayfield, there’s a shared excitement among sports fishermen for the first Saturday in May—traditionally Wisconsin’s fishing opener. As early as 5 am, fishermen launch their boats out into the Apostle Islands to try their luck at reeling in some of the most prized catches of Lake Superior: brown trout, lake trout, and coho salmon.

You don’t need to be a seasoned local fisherman to get in on the action. Whether you’re a first-timer or a seasoned pro, there’s a spot for everyone to enjoy fishing in Bayfield. 

Get ready to cast your line and dive into one of Lake Superior’s most rewarding sports next time you visit us at Seagull Bay. This blog will be your guide to some of the best fishing charters in our area.

Set Your Lines with One of These Fishing Charters in Bayfield, Wisconsin 

When planning a fishing trip in Bayfield, you don’t have to go it alone. 

Bayfield is home to several excellent fishing charters specializing in everything from lake trout, browns, coho salmon, and splake. These charters offer all the equipment, know-how, and guidance you’ll need to make your fishing experience as smooth as possible.

Here are a few of our favorite local charters that’ll help you reel in a catch to remember:

1. Beyond the Catch

Beyond the Catch offers unforgettable fishing adventures aboard the Outer Limits, a 31-foot Tiara Open Yacht. With half-day and full-day trips for up to six people, you’ll head out from Port Superior Marina and take in stunning views of the Apostle Islands with Captain Tommy Hicks.

Captain Hicks, a lifelong Ashland native, grew up fishing the Chequamegon Bay and Apostle Islands. After serving as first mate to the late Jim Hudson, he’s been a licensed US Coast Guard-certified captain since 2013.

Beyond the Catch provides state-of-the-art equipment, bait, tackle, and ice so you can focus on enjoying the catch of the day year-round.

2. Superior Sport Fishing

Superior Sport Fishing offers charter fishing in Bayfield, Wisconsin. Trips launch from the Red Cliff Marina into the heart of the Apostle Islands. Here, you’ll experience the beauty of Lake Superior while chasing game fish like lake trout, brown trout, coho, king salmon, and more. 

Charters are led by Coast Guard-certified Captain Tom Linderholm and accomplished tournament fisherman Captain Jim Jonasen. And they supply you with all the right gear, knowledge, and experience needed to land the big one. 

From May to September, you can access the area’s best fishing spots and picturesque views of the Apostle Islands National Lakeshore.

3. DS Charter Services and Sports Fishing

DS Charter Services offers guided sport fishing on Lake Superior, led by experienced US Coast Guard-certified Captain Josh Brzezinski. Climb aboard the fully equipped Grady White 265 Express, launching from Bayfield, Washburn, or Saxon, Wisconsin, and head out into the clear waters of Lake Superior.

Accommodating groups of up to six, DS Charters provides everything you need for a successful day of fishing. And they help you clean and package your catch! All you need to bring are snacks, drinks, and a cooler to take your fish home. Get ready for a day of fun on Lake Superior!

5. Eliminator Sports Fishing

Step on the 33-foot Tiara, the Northern Comfort, with Eliminator Sports Fishing. This top-of-the-line fishing vessel is run by Coast Guard-certified Captain Zander Ziemski. Equipped with the latest Garmin electronics and top-notch fishing gear, the Northern Comfort gives you and your crew the safety and flexibility of fishing up to 40 miles offshore. 

Captain Zander has been fishing on Lake Superior since he was 6 years old, learning from some of the best captains around. With his tournament fishing experience and passion for the Apostle Islands, he’s eager to provide you with a memorable day on the lake. 

He’ll send you off with fresh fish, cleaned, bagged, and ready to throw on the grill back at Seagull Bay.

Enjoy One of Lake Superior’s Most Valuable Resources When You Stay at Seagull Bay in Bayfield, Wisconsin

Fishing in Bayfield is about more than reeling in a catch—it’s about connecting with the area’s natural beauty. 

Lake Superior is one of the world’s largest and cleanest freshwater lakes, offering some of the most pristine, untouched fishing grounds you’ll find anywhere. 

Whether casting your line from a boat in the warmer months or braving the winter elements ice fishing, every season in Bayfield brings a new and exciting way to enjoy the lake and surrounding landscape.

And when you stay at Seagull Bay, you’re not just booking a room—you’re setting yourself up for a perfect adventure. 

Our lakeside location offers stunning views of Lake Superior and is a short drive from Bayfield, Wisconsin’s best fishing charters. 

After a long day of fishing, you’ll have a comfortable and welcoming place to return to—complete with shared balconies, modern design, and breathtaking views inviting you to unwind after a rewarding day on the water.

Book your room and get ready to go fishing in Bayfield, Wisconsin. 

Your Memories with a View!

Mollie, Isaac, Axel, Ridge, and Banks

QUICK LINKS:
Beyond The Catch 

Superior Sport Fishing 

DS Charter ServicesEliminator Sports Fishing