For years, Seagull Bay Motel has been a proud sponsor of Book Across the Bay. It’s the most iconic winter event held in the Chequamegon Bay area. It draws outdoor enthusiasts from near and far to experience the unique thrill of crossing the ice of Lake Superior under the stars. 

The Book Across the Bay is more than a 10K ski and snowshoe race—it’s a celebration of the winter season, the natural beauty of our area, and the spirit of adventure.

Whether you’re a seasoned athlete or a first-time participant, it’s the perfect opportunity to experience the magic of Lake Superior.

Fuel up before your race, or relax and unwind after the event in our area’s vibrant dining scene. Here, you can savor Bayfield’s fresh, local flavors and cuisine. 

In this guide, we’ve rounded up our top 5 favorite restaurants in Bayfield and the surrounding area, perfect for skiers and snowshoers after an action-packed day. Whether you’re craving a hearty meal, a warm drink, or a cozy place to relax with your new race day buddies, these local restaurants offer a variety of flavors to refuel and refresh.

Seagull Bay’s favorite restaurants in Bayfield for skiers & snowshoers

Bayfield’s dining scene is full of flavor, offering something for everyone. You’ll find a creative new spin on your favorite comfort food, fresh-caught Lake Superior fish, and a cozy spot to unwind after a night on the ice or a day on the trails. 

These local restaurants are perfect for fueling up before an adventure or enjoying a well-earned break afterward. Here are some of our top picks:

1. St. James Social: Modern elegance meets Bayfield’s historic charm

If you’re looking for a unique dining experience with a blend of historic charm and modern flair, look no further than St. James Social. 

Bayfield’s newest restaurant offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere perfect for Book Across the Bay participants seeking a cozy spot to unwind after the race. St. James Social offers a carefully curated menu of seasonal dishes made from locally-sourced ingredients guaranteed to excite your taste buds. 

St. James is also known for its craft cocktails and mocktails, perfect for toasting to your accomplishments after the race or your day of outdoor exploration. 

St. James has something for everyone: a hearty meal, wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizza, and even a Sunday disco brunch! The elegant yet comfortable atmosphere makes it an ideal place to gather with friends and loved ones, share stories from the day, and indulge in delicious food and drink.

Whether you’re celebrating your Book Across the Bay finish or simply enjoying the beauty of Bayfield in winter, this spot offers an unforgettable dining experience.

Good Thyme: A cozy local favorite near Bayfield

For those who love comfort food done well, Good Thyme Restaurant & Catering is a must. Located just outside Bayfield (and on your way back from the finish line for Book Across the Bay *wink wink*), this cozy spot is a local favorite, offering warm hospitality and a full menu of good food.

Some of our favorite dishes include their infamous Double-Smashed Burger, Mussels Marinere, Hand-Cut Ribeye, and Sesame Soy Vinaigrette (yes, even their house salad dressing is worth mentioning!). 

Good Thyme provides the perfect place to indulge in delicious food, sip a satisfying glass of wine, and leave with a night to remember. 

Reservations are highly recommended if you plan on stopping here during your visit.

Pier Plaza Restaurant: A historic waterfront restaurant in Bayfield 

If you’re looking for a classic Bayfield experience, head to the Pier Plaza Restaurant above the Bayfield City Dock. This local institution has been serving delicious meals since 1937, offering a taste of Bayfield’s rich history along with great food. 

The Pier Plaza’s friendly atmosphere and beautiful lake views make it a perfect spot to unwind after your adventure on the trails or the lake.

Known for its take on classic dishes, the Pier Plaza specializes in fresh, locally-caught fish. Trust me, you don’t want to miss their famous fish fry! 

If you’re craving a warm and filling meal after spending time outdoors, you can’t go wrong with freshly caught whitefish or trout served alongside fries and a cold drink. Plus, its location on Bayfield’s waterfront adds to the charm. Here, you can watch locals drive back and forth on the ice road to Madeline Island while savoring delicious food.

The Pier Plaza offers a relaxed and inviting place to eat that’s sure to please.

Coco: A flavorful stop for breakfast, lunch, or a sweet treat

If you’re looking for a fun and colorful spot to dine, Coco is the place to be. 

Known for its creative, locally-sourced menu, Coco offers everything from hearty breakfasts to satisfying lunches and delectable treats. Imagine starting your day with a perfectly brewed cup of coffee and a homemade cinnamon roll or loading up on carbs with one of their artisan sandwiches before the big event.

Co-owner and pâtissier Noreen Ovadia Wills takes pride in their menu’s bold, artful flavors. Options range from light bites like locally grown rhubarb turnovers and seasonal salads to heartier fare such as house-made soups and Bob & Sadie’s Excellent Chicken Bento Box. 

For those looking to satisfy a sweet tooth, their selection of pastries—including croissants, cookies, and cakes—make it easy to indulge in a little pre-adventure treat.

Whether you’re gearing up for a winter adventure or heading home Sunday morning after Book Across the Bay, Coco offers a laid-back yet elevated dining experience that’s sure to impress even the most discerning food lover.

Wonderstate Cafe: The perfect stop for coffee and light bites

Sometimes all you need is a warm drink and a quick bite before hitting the trails. Wonderstate Cafe in Bayfield is the perfect spot for both. 

Known for its exceptional coffee and freshly baked pastries, Wonderstate offers a cozy, relaxed environment where you can enjoy a moment of calm before Book Across the Bay. It’s also the perfect place to recharge on Sunday morning.

Stop by for a velvety smooth latte or a homemade cranberry scone, and enjoy the friendly local vibe. Wonderstate Cafe is the ideal place to start your day.

Seagull Bay: The perfect starting point for Book Across the Bay and culinary adventures

After a day of skiing or snowshoeing across Lake Superior, there’s no better way to unwind than with a great meal at one of our favorite restaurants in Bayfield. 

Bayfield offers a dining experience to match every taste, from elegant spots like St. James Social and Good Thyme to local favorites like Pier Plaza and Coco. For the perfect coffee break, Wonderstate Cafe has you covered. Whether fueling up before an adventure or unwinding afterward, you’ll find plenty of delicious options within a few minutes’ drive of Seagull Bay.

At Seagull Bay, we’re proud to be part of Book Across the Bay, and we can’t wait to welcome you to our winter wonderland. 

Book your stay with us today and enjoy all that Bayfield has to offer—from the great outdoors to the unforgettable dining experiences that await you after your adventure. 

Your Memories with a View!

Mollie, Isaac, Axel, Ridge, and Banks

QUICK LINKS:

Book Across The Bay 

St. James Social Lounge & Restaurant

Good Thyme Restaurant

The Pier Plaza

Cafe Coco Wonderstate Cafe