Nestled among the vibrant blooms of a meticulously cared-for cottage garden, The Mill House offers a front-row seat to Bayfield’s inviting downtown. A half block from Memorial Park—where free lakeside concerts fill the summer air—you’ll find yourself surrounded by the sights, sounds, and easy rhythm of Bayfield life.
One block from the Bayfield City Dock and Marina, this five-suite property blends comfort and convenience with the character of a lakeside getaway. From Bayfield’s First Street, you’ll catch partial views of the harbor and have effortless access to nearby restaurants, shops, and parks. Each suite features modern amenities and a home-like feel—ideal for couples, small families, or friends who want to stay close to everything Bayfield has to offer.
The Mill House offers five individually styled suites, each designed to give you space to relax while keeping you connected to Bayfield’s downtown energy. With kitchenettes, cozy living areas, and private decks overlooking Bayfield’s First Street and summer gardens, you’ll have everything you need for an easy, memorable stay.
Downtown Bayfield location steps from restaurants, shops, and marinas
King, queen, and twin beds for a comfortable night's sleep
Private decks or shared patios surrounded by a cottage garden
Suites with kitchenettes and one or two bedrooms
Partial lake and harbor views from select suites
Bayfield is brimming with outdoor adventures, local events, and renowned festivals.
To help you plan the ultimate Bayfield vacation, we’ve created a seasonal guide filled with the best our area offers.
Enter your email, and we’ll send it right to your inbox so you can start planning your getaway.
In the meantime,
memories are waiting to be created.
We can't wait to share the Best Little Town in the Midwest with you! Click the link below to download your guide.
We’re the Carriers – Isaac and Mollie. We’re the ones behind the desk, answering the phone, changing the laundry, and pushing the cleaning cart – alongside our amazing staff.
In 2016, after our son Axel was born, Isaac got the idea to move back to his hometown of Bayfield, Wisconsin. The crazy part is he wanted to buy a motel.
In 2017, with an 11-month-old (and another on the way), we took the leap and purchased Seagull Bay Motel.
Since then, we’ve been raising our three boys and restoring our lakeside motel and adjoining properties to create a welcoming and peaceful atmosphere just for you.
There are many reasons to pack your bags and stay at Seagull Bay, but don’t take our word for it!
“I’ve been coming to Seagull Bay for over 30 years and always feared it would someday be replaced by a new, modern, but cookie-cutter, hotel. But you Carriers have done an OUTSTANDING job of keeping what so many of us longtime customers LOVED about the place Mike and Jeannie created. But enhancing it in the most wonderful ways (I LOVE the new bedding…) I used to come to Bayfield and Seagull Bay to escape the demands of a rigorous job and just BREATH for a while. Now that I’m retired, I still anticipate and enjoy what it has always been – a lovely, calm, and peaceful place to be. Well done, Carriers.”
~ Nancy
“Such a great, old-fashioned ‘Mom & Pop’ vibe! Having the walking trail just down the stairs is such a nice way to walk to the shops and restaurants in town. We attended our first Big Top Chautauqua show, and the free shuttle stopping there was such a huge bonus.”
~ Sue Ann
“Quaint hotel with sweeping views of the bay. We had a second-floor room that included a shared balcony which was a lovely spot for morning coffee. The coffee maker in the room made a surprisingly good cup. Nothing fancy about this classic upgraded motel but very clean and charming place to spend a night.”
~ Paul T
“A clean, charming motel with attention to detail. You could tell the owners care about their property and their customers. Wonderful lake views sitting on the deck or just looking out your window. Access to the walking trail makes for an easy walk into town.”
~ Deb K
